More Than Automation: Why Human Expertise Still Matters in an AI-Driven Business
Artificial intelligence is changing how businesses create content, deliver services, and compete. Tasks that once required hours of work can now be completed in minutes. For agencies and consultancies, that shift raises an important question: if AI can do more of the delivery work, what should a business actually be built around?
For Matt Thomas, founder of Stake Reputation, the answer lies in human expertise.
In this episode of The Growth Equation, Matt joins Tristan Wright to discuss building a senior-led consultancy, using AI effectively, and preserving the human judgment that makes professional services valuable.
From opera singer to business owner
Matt’s professional journey is anything but conventional. He spent approximately 15 years working as a professional opera singer while maintaining a parallel career in marketing and communications.
That experience gave him more than an unusual career story. Performing complex characters required him to understand their motivations, emotions, and perspectives—even when those characters behaved in difficult or confronting ways.
Matt sees a direct connection between that experience and effective communications. Understanding an audience requires the ability to step into someone else’s shoes, consider what motivates them, and communicate in a way that resonates.
After returning his focus to communications full-time, Matt worked across consultancies and agencies before establishing Stake Reputation. His interest in the intersection between brand and reputation helped shape the business.
Building a business around experienced people
When Matt established Stake, he recognised that AI was already changing the economics of agency work. Content creation, writing, and the production of multiple campaign variations were becoming faster and easier to automate.
Rather than building a traditional agency with senior leaders overseeing a large team of junior delivery staff, Matt chose a different model.
Stake is built around experienced professionals who can bring strategic thinking, sound judgment, and strong client relationships to the work.
The distinction matters because clients don’t always arrive with a clearly defined problem. They may have identified a symptom or requested a particular deliverable without fully understanding what needs to change.
Helping them uncover the real problem requires thoughtful questioning, context, and experience.
AI can help produce possible solutions, but someone still needs to determine whether those solutions address the right problem.
AI makes production faster, but judgment still takes time
One of the clearest examples Matt shares is content production. Work that once required a junior team member to write multiple versions of a content deck can now be generated by AI in minutes.
However, generating the first draft is only part of the process.
The output still needs to be reviewed, refined, and adjusted to ensure the right nuance, strategy, and context are present. Faster production doesn’t automatically mean better work.
Matt also treats AI much like an employee. It needs adequate information, clear instructions, and feedback to deliver useful results.
Poor inputs can create more work rather than less. Without a well-defined brief, teams can spend longer correcting generic or unsuitable output than they would have spent planning the task properly.
The opportunity isn’t simply to use more AI. It’s to learn how to direct it well.
The challenge of developing future expertise
Perhaps the most important issue raised in the conversation is what happens to early-career professionals as AI takes over more entry-level work.
Traditionally, junior employees develop their skills by completing foundational tasks, observing experienced colleagues, and learning how decisions are made. They also gain valuable experience by seeing problems unfold and helping resolve them.
If businesses eliminate these opportunities without creating new ways to develop talent, where will the next generation of experienced professionals come from?
Matt questions how organisations can continue to build judgment, commercial awareness, and original thinking when fewer people are exposed to the work that develops those skills.
It’s a challenge that extends beyond marketing and communications. Many industries rely on practical experience to turn knowledge into expertise.
Businesses adopting AI need to consider not only what technology can replace today, but also how they will develop the people they need tomorrow.
Running a small business means learning the financial details
Matt’s experience also highlights a less glamorous part of entrepreneurship: managing cash flow.
After years of working alongside finance professionals, becoming a business owner meant taking direct responsibility for working capital, payment terms, payroll, and planning the company’s financial runway.
Long payment terms from large clients can create real pressure for small consultancies that must pay employees and contractors before invoices are settled.
Matt also reflects on the early decision to absorb some project costs to build case studies. While those projects helped establish the business, taking additional costs out of the margin created a lesson in balancing growth opportunities with commercial discipline.
Winning work is important. Understanding the cost of delivering it, protecting margins, and managing when cash arrives are equally important.
Protecting client confidentiality when using AI
AI adoption also requires clear boundaries.
Matt explains that Stake has systems for protecting confidential information and that some work is still handled the traditional way rather than putting sensitive client details into AI tools.
This is an important reminder that AI implementation isn’t only about productivity. Businesses need to consider privacy, confidentiality, appropriate use, and the consequences of sharing information with external systems.
A useful AI workflow should improve delivery without compromising client trust.
Entrepreneurship doesn’t have to be a lonely experience
When asked what advice he would give other business owners at a similar stage, Matt emphasises the importance of building a network.
Running a business can feel lonely even when you have a capable team around you. Having other business owners to talk to provides a sounding board for decisions, reassurance that certain challenges are common, and opportunities to learn from shared experience.
You don’t need to solve every problem in isolation.
Building a business for the future
Matt’s approach offers a useful perspective on the future of professional services. AI can increase productivity, accelerate delivery, and help experienced teams work more efficiently. But the strongest businesses will still need people who can understand clients, exercise judgment, challenge assumptions, and make decisions in complex situations.
The goal isn’t to choose between technology and human expertise. It’s to build a model in which each strengthens the other.
As AI becomes more capable, the ability to ask the right questions, identify the real problem, and apply experience thoughtfully may become even more valuable.
Listen to Episode 82 of The Growth Equation, featuring Matt Thomas of Stake Reputation, for a deeper conversation about AI, human expertise, and building a business that can thrive through change.
